Abuse Report
1 .  Thread's URL
2 .  Comment
3 .  Your Name
4 .  E-mail
    




User Name   Password
Views:564     

<<Previous ThreadNext Thread>>
Page 1 of 1    
Author Comment
Silverrapier
| Move to Bottom
 
Author



Rank:none
Status:
Score: 0
Posts: 16
From:
Registered: 02/20/2008
Time spent: 0 hours

(Date Posted:02/23/2008 18:08:50)

I was just reading through my Montaigne nation book when I caught this little tidbit on page 67 in Pascal Venstanzi's bio:

"But one afternoon, a passing Fate witch yelled as a letter she was reading war torn from her hands (by the wind)..."

It is said expressly that Fate witches are not allowed to be litterate, so why is every Strega NPC in every source book actually able to read? It's especially annoying when you have a Fate witch PC who keeps throwing that in your face whenever you insist that "no, you can't learn to read".



Lady Grace
| Move to Top | Move to Bottom
 
1#



Rank:none
Status:
Score:0
Posts:1183
From:
Registered: 06/02/2003
Time spent: 0 hours

RE:Anybody else catch that?
(Date Posted:02/23/2008 19:07:51)

  Oh believe me, you're not the only one who hates seeing literate PC Fate Witches seemingly reading out in the open without consequences constantly...:p

--------------------------------------------------------------
"Ulf, just because you drank six tankards of Vesten mead and shout "I'm the Oncoming Storm!" does not --I repeat-- does NOT automatically make you a Berserker!" -- Fortunato Valari

_Cristina_
| Move to Top | Move to Bottom
 
2#



Status:
From:
Registered: 01/19/2008
Time spent: 0 hours

RE:Anybody else catch that?
(Date Posted:02/23/2008 21:36:52)

If you were quoting from the Vodacce book, you would have a valid point. Since the offending passage is in the Montaigne book,  you may not.

Anyway, how do you know that she is reading a language? She may be reading pictographs, glyphs, or even Sorte pictures.


(Message edited by _Cristina_ on 02/23/2008 21:40:51)
Silverrapier
| Move to Top | Move to Bottom
 
3#



Status:
From:
Registered: 02/20/2008
Time spent: 0 hours

Reply To _Cristina_
(Date Posted:02/25/2008 06:20:27)

If you were quoting from the Vodacce book, you would have a valid point. Since the offending passage is in the Montaigne book,  you may not.

Anyway, how do you know that she is reading a language? She may be reading pictographs, glyphs, or even Sorte pictures.


Well, the incident did take place in Vodacce according to the book, but if your point is that the Montaigne book predates the Vodacce one, the fact that noblewomen are not allowed to read  is  also  in  the  player's  and  game  master's  guide.

As for your second point, that's always a possibility, but it wouldn't be the first time there were discrepancies between the various source books.

Anyway, my main point was a fate witch pc who absolutely wants to be litterate. I guess I'll just have to get her in trouble for it.
Rebecca Iavelli
| Move to Top | Move to Bottom
 
4#



Rank:none
Status:
Score:0
Posts:1113
From:
Registered: 04/01/2004
Time spent: 0 hours

RE:Anybody else catch that?
(Date Posted:02/25/2008 19:44:09)

Well, only the noble women of Vodacce are not  taught to read, as long as they are in Vodacce, under the control of their husbands. (There are a few that are or have been taught secretly, as stated in  one  of the books, Vodacce I believe, on page 52 upper left paragraph.)

But in the RPG game, most of those that play Sorte Strega, I being one of them, usually play the "runaway" type, and over a course of time, can learn to read, if given the chance, or the need or even want.

Playing a true to form Vodacce Fatewitch, would mostly mean that the adventure would either stay in Vodacce, or that she is off somewhere with her husband in some other part of Theah.  While that may be an interesting game, there is more of the world of Theah to explore, and while there are other characters people can choose to be and do that exploring, I decide I liked the idea of a Runaway Fatewitch, the magic, the idea of the plot of having family hunting her.

I am lucky enough to have a GM that has no problem with a Fatewitch that can read, because I gave him good reason why she does.  When she ran away, she "paid" her way onto a boat with her only inheiritance she had from her mother, a pearl necklace, but later that ship, which had actually been a pirate ship, was captured and all sent to La Bucca, including my character.  Acording to the time line we play by, she was there for a while, and  durning the time there, made friends with other prisoners, one who just happened to be a Vendel Merchant's daughter (another pc), that taught her how to read and write.   

Learning how to read and write is not hard,  and the Sorte Strega are not "dumb".  Any that escaped from Vodacce, in my own opinion, would want to learn to read for themselves, to know for themselves, rather than have someone read to them, because people can and will lie, depending on circumstances, and with the talent of the Sorte, I would think that they would be able to tell, if they were "looking", that the person was lying to them.  Remember, they are from Vodacce, where telling the truth  out right is not the most popular of conversations, unless the person telling  it will get some personal gain from the use of  it.

So while most Sorte Strega in Vodacce  are probably the good little stay-at-home-never-read types, it is the ones who run away that are focused upon, for the adventures and the RPG; and yes, a woman on her own has got to use every advantage she can get, so she has to learn what-ever she can to survive, including reading.

If your PC has given a good reason and has paid points for the ability, I don't see why she can't, but also if she is seen reading by another Vodacce, yes, they may give her a hard time for it, just don't make it so bad that she would not want to play anymore. The whole idea of it all is to have fun.

--------------------------------------------------------------
Fate, a four letter word, with a lot of strings attached.
-------------------------------
"We Pay to Plunder!!"
-------------------------------
The price of anything is the amount of life you exchange for it.
Henry David Thoreau
--------------------------------
Do not mettle in the affairs of Dragons...for you are crunchy and tastey with ketchup.

_Cristina_
| Move to Top | Move to Bottom
 
5#



Status:
From:
Registered: 01/19/2008
Time spent: 0 hours

Reply To Silverrapier
(Date Posted:02/27/2008 00:05:54)

If you were quoting from the Vodacce book, you would have a valid point. Since the offending passage is in the Montaigne book,  you may not.

Anyway, how do you know that she is reading a language? She may be reading pictographs, glyphs, or even Sorte pictures.


Well, the incident did take place in Vodacce according to the book, but if your point is that the Montaigne book predates the Vodacce one, the fact that noblewomen are not allowed to read  is  also  in  the  player's  and  game  master's  guide.

As for your second point, that's always a possibility, but it wouldn't be the first time there were discrepancies between the various source books.

Anyway, my main point was a fate witch pc who absolutely wants to be litterate. I guess I'll just have to get her in trouble for it.


IMO the AEG editors were pretty laissez faire when it came to consistency in coordinating their freelancers.

It may be a crime in Theah for Vodacce noblewomen to read; but it's also a crime to kill and to steal as well, but laws against these don't seem all that effective either. The Inquisition has some laws, but these seem to be flaunted a lot too.
slapstick
| Move to Top
 
6#



Rank:none
Status:
Score:0
Posts:316
From:
Registered: 06/01/2004
Time spent: 0 hours

RE:Anybody else catch that?
(Date Posted:03/03/2008 14:59:05)

I  honestly don't understand the obsession with runaway  literate Fate Witches - after all, reading is for whores, and Strega have it better than 99% of the population, as they never worry about where their next meal is coming from or sleeping in a leaky, one-room farm house with their entire family.

The fact that every Vodacce man  is a total asshole who  WILL  hit/berate/urinate on his betrothed probably explains why they beat feet! ;)

If a player wants to be  a witch who reads, have fun  and use it to present difficult situations.  Have her make bad with a Bernoulli with some influence who gets a hold of a letter or even forges one to present to the Inquisition as proof of her heresy,  or another Vodacce she thought was a friend  blackmail her, lest she be sent to a  nunnery. Have another witch fiddle with her strands so that words look like nonsense, or read the opposite of what they really say, leading to horrific misunderstandings.

--------------------------------------------------------------
"What a fun, sexy time for you."

 Welcome to The Collection of Flashlights!Wolf-eyes ,your eyes break the darkness!
Hop to: 
<<Previous ThreadNext Thread>>
Page 1 of 1    

WOW Gold   CD Keys   Buy WOW Gold   Shareware Free Download   Free Message Board  Flashlight  WOW CD key  RC helicopter  
Sign Up | Create | About us | SiteMap | Features | Forums | Show Off | Faq | Support
Copyright © 2000-2008 Aimoo free forum All rights reserved.